Authorized AMSOIL Dealer
JONATHAN L LACKMAN
Castle Pines, CO
Independent AMSOIL Dealer · Jonathan Lackman · Denver, CO Ships nationwide from AMSOIL · Not the official AMSOIL site

Can you mix AMSOIL with other oil?

I earn a commission when you buy or join through my links · Disclosure

Quick answer

Yes. AMSOIL motor oils are compatible with other conventional and synthetic motor oils, so mixing won’t damage your engine. The catch is what you give up: AMSOIL says mixing shortens the oil’s life and reduces its benefits, AMSOIL doesn’t support extended drain intervals on mixed oil, and mixing other oils with AMSOIL motor oil voids the AMSOIL Limited Warranty. In a pinch, top off with any oil of the same viscosity and spec, then change on your vehicle maker’s normal interval.

Short answer: yes, and it’s not a big deal for your engine. The longer answer is about what mixing does to your interval and to AMSOIL’s warranty, which is why people ask.

Is AMSOIL compatible with other motor oils?

Yes. AMSOIL’s FAQ and its data sheets say the same thing: AMSOIL synthetic motor oils are compatible with other conventional and synthetic motor oils. Topping off with another brand won’t hurt the engine.

What do you lose when you mix?

Three things, all from AMSOIL’s own wording:

  1. Life and performance. Mixing “will shorten the oil’s life expectancy and reduce its performance benefits.”
  2. Extended drains. “AMSOIL does not support extended drain intervals where oils have been mixed.” So no 25,000-mile run on a mixed fill.
  3. AMSOIL’s warranty. “Mixing other oils with AMSOIL motor oils will also void the AMSOIL Limited Warranty.” Your vehicle maker’s warranty is a separate thing; see does AMSOIL void your warranty?

What should I do in my situation?

Mixing scenarios and what to do
SituationIs it OK?What I’d do
Low on oil, only another brand availableYesAdd the same viscosity and spec. Change on the factory interval, not AMSOIL’s extended one.
Switching from Mobil 1, Pennzoil, etc. to AMSOILYesDo a full oil and filter change. No flush needed for a well-maintained engine.
Topped off Signature Series with OE or Extended-LifeEngine is fineTreat the fill as the shorter-rated oil’s interval.
Mixed 5W-30 with 5W-20 in a pinchShort termCorrect to the manual viscosity at the next change.
Mixed ATFs with different friction specsNoUse the fluid your transmission’s spec calls for. Mixing friction types can cause shift problems.
Topped off gear oil with another brandCompatibleExpect a shorter interval; minimize mixing viscosities.
Based on AMSOIL’s FAQ and data sheets (G2880, G3831). Always match your owner’s manual spec and viscosity.

Can you mix AMSOIL with Mobil 1 or Royal Purple?

Yes, the same rules apply to any brand. People ask about Mobil 1 and Royal Purple most because they’re the common switches. Match the viscosity and spec, and change the mixed fill on the normal interval.

AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30 synthetic motor oil quart bottle

Can you mix AMSOIL products with each other?

AMSOIL actually recommends not mixing its own lubricants, because each is formulated for its application. Its example: topping off Signature Series 5W-30 with OE 5W-30 is fine for the engine because they share similar chemistry, but it shortens Signature Series’ life and cancels the extended interval.

The bigger risk is with transmission fluids. AMSOIL says some transmissions need specific frictional properties, and mixing fluids made for different specs can cause erratic shifting or transmission failure. See transmission fluid for the right ATF by truck.

For 2-stroke premix, ratios and products are on the premix ratio chart.

How do I switch to AMSOIL the right way?

  1. Drain the old oil fully with the engine warm.
  2. Install a new filter. AMSOIL recommends an AMSOIL filter at every change; with another brand of filter, AMSOIL caps the interval at 12,000 miles or one year on gasoline engines.
  3. Fill with the AMSOIL grade your vehicle lookup shows.
  4. If the engine has a poor maintenance history or visible sludge, AMSOIL suggests its Engine and Transmission Flush first. Well-maintained engines don’t need it.
  5. For your first AMSOIL fill, stay on the factory interval. If you want to stretch intervals later, read will AMSOIL really last 25,000 miles?

Find the right AMSOIL for your vehicle

Mobil 1, Royal Purple and Pennzoil are trademarks of their owners, used for identification only.

Frequently asked questions

Can you mix AMSOIL with Mobil 1?
Yes. AMSOIL says its motor oils are compatible with other conventional and synthetic oils, which includes Mobil 1. Use the same viscosity. The mixed fill should be changed on the vehicle maker’s interval, not AMSOIL’s extended interval, and AMSOIL’s Limited Warranty doesn’t cover mixed oil.
Can I mix AMSOIL with regular (conventional) oil?
Yes, it’s compatible. It dilutes the synthetic, so expect the mix to behave more like the weaker oil. Change it at the normal factory interval.
Can I top off AMSOIL with a different brand on a trip?
Yes. Running low on oil is far worse than mixing. Add a quart of the same viscosity that meets your owner’s manual spec, then plan your next change on the factory interval instead of an extended one.
Can I mix Signature Series and OE or Extended-Life?
AMSOIL says same-viscosity Signature Series and OE share similar chemistry and the engine will run fine, but mixing shortens Signature Series’ life and AMSOIL doesn’t support extended drains on mixed oil. AMSOIL’s general advice is not to mix its own lubricants either.
Can I mix different viscosities, like 5W-30 and 5W-20?
In an emergency top-off, a small amount won’t hurt, but it shifts the viscosity. Use your manual’s viscosity whenever you can and correct it at the next change.
Do I need to flush when switching to AMSOIL?
No. AMSOIL says there are no special requirements for switching to its synthetic oil. In older engines with a poor maintenance history, AMSOIL suggests its Engine and Transmission Flush first. Change the filter at every switch.
Can I mix AMSOIL transmission fluid or gear oil with what’s in there?
AMSOIL says its transmission fluids are compatible with petroleum and synthetic ATFs and can be used to top off, and its gear lubes are compatible with other synthetic and petroleum gear oils. Don’t mix ATFs made for different friction specifications. For gear oil, mixing viscosities can change the result and the drain interval.

Sources

Product facts on this page come from AMSOIL’s official product pages and literature. Always follow your owner’s manual.

  1. AMSOIL FAQ: Can AMSOIL motor oils be mixed with other brands? / Can AMSOIL lubricants be safely mixed together?
  2. AMSOIL Signature Series data sheet (G2880, 11/26): Compatibility
  3. AMSOIL High-Mileage Motor Oil data sheet (G3831, 12/25): Compatibility