AMSOIL vs Valvoline: the published head-to-head data
Quick answer
AMSOIL currently publishes one dated head-to-head against a Valvoline product: in the TEOST 33C deposit test (ASTM D6335), AMSOIL High-Mileage 0W-20 formed 15.4 mg of deposits vs 39.3 mg for Valvoline Full Synthetic High-Mileage with MaxLife Technology 0W-20 (Valvoline sample purchased December 21, 2022). That is a high-mileage 0W-20 test, not a comparison of Signature Series to Valvoline’s flagship Advanced oil.
Valvoline is one of the oils people already have in the garage, so they ask how it stacks up. Same rule as the Mobil 1 page: I only use tests AMSOIL currently publishes, with the dates and methods attached.
The head-to-head: high-mileage 0W-20 deposits
| AMSOIL 0W-20 High-Mileage | Valvoline Full Synthetic High-Mileage with MaxLife Technology 0W-20 | Mobil 1 High-Mileage 0W-20 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total deposits (mg) | 15.4 | 39.3 | 40.5 |
AMSOIL High-Mileage 0W-20 left well under half the deposits of either competitor in this high-temperature deposit test. AMSOIL describes it as up to 62% better deposit prevention. TEOST 33C is designed to stress oil the way a turbocharger does.
That’s a real result, and it is narrowly scoped: high-mileage 0W-20 oils bought in late 2022. It does not automatically rank Signature Series above Valvoline Advanced, or Max-Duty above a Valvoline diesel oil.
What about the flagship oils?
For Signature Series, AMSOIL’s current published claims compare it to industry standards, not to a named Valvoline product:
- 72% more protection against piston deposits than industry standards (5W-30, Sequence IIIH), and 31% better than required even in a double-length test.
- 2X better protection against volatility than the API SQ limit (0W-20, ASTM D5800 NOACK).
- Up to 25,000 miles or one year in normal service with an AMSOIL filter, backed by AMSOIL’s Limited Warranty.
- In AMSOIL’s 125,000-mile study in a 2025 Ford F-150 Raptor 3.5L high-output engine on 25,000-mile drains, horsepower and torque were maintained.
Diesel is a different comparison
If the question is really about a diesel pickup, don’t use this gasoline high-mileage test. See the diesel oil guide and AMSOIL vs Shell Rotella.
How I’d decide
- You want the longest guaranteed interval: Signature Series. See Signature Series vs Extended-Life vs OE.
- High-mileage gas engine: AMSOIL High-Mileage has the deposit data above and a 12,000-mile/1-year rating.
- Diesel truck: use the diesel oil guide, not this test.
- You also want the Mobil 1 numbers from the same test: AMSOIL vs Mobil 1.
AMSOIL Signature Series 0W-20 100% Synthetic Motor Oil (ASM)
Best for: Gas engines that call for 0W-20 and owners who want AMSOIL’s longest interval.
- Guaranteed protection up to 25,000 miles or 1 year (normal service)
- 2X better protection against volatility vs. the API SQ limit
- Meets API SQ, GM dexos1 Gen 3 and Ford WSS-M2C947-A/B1 (AMSOIL G2880)
Tip: Preferred Customers get member pricing. Join at AMSOIL.com
Read all of AMSOIL’s published performance tests
Valvoline and MaxLife are trademarks of Valvoline; Mobil 1 is a trademark of Exxon Mobil Corporation; Ford, F-150 and Raptor are trademarks of Ford Motor Company. Used only for comparison and identification. No affiliation or endorsement is implied. Test results describe the products tested on the dates listed and may not apply to later formulations. AMSOIL is a registered trademark of AMSOIL INC.; I’m an Independent AMSOIL Dealer, not AMSOIL INC.
Frequently asked questions
Is AMSOIL better than Valvoline?
Did AMSOIL test Signature Series against Valvoline Advanced?
How long does AMSOIL last compared to Valvoline?
Can I switch from Valvoline to AMSOIL?
Sources
Product facts on this page come from AMSOIL’s official product pages and literature. Always follow your owner’s manual.